What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Engine Forum Archives

Moderator: Ranchero50

Locked
User avatar
robroy
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 3768
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 4:36 pm
Location: California, Salinas

What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by robroy »

Good afternoon!

At the risk of having redundant threads I thought I'd ask about this here.

#50's new engine is now running but makes a bad tapping/cracking noise. Here's a video that shows off the noise pretty well. EDIT: This video is encoded using a very modern format. New video software can play it, such as VLC 1.0.3, Windows Media Player 12, Apple Quicktime 7, and the iPhone, but older software cannot.

http://www.robroygregg.com/Number50/Num ... dRun_A.avi

I'm hoping this is just exhaust leaking at the collectors, but I'm not sure. It seems like it sounds loudest all around in the engine bay (not as loud under the truck). That narrows it down a whole lot doesn't it? :)

Anybody care to take a listen and guess? Also, any suggestions on anything feasible I can do to determine whether it's an exhaust leak or not?

Thanks very much!
Robroy
Last edited by robroy on Fri Nov 27, 2009 6:09 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
DuckRyder
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 4893
Joined: Mon Jul 19, 2004 3:04 pm
Location: Scruffy City
Contact:

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by DuckRyder »

It is very hard to tell from the video.

Take a long (and I mean long like pry-bar long) screwdriver, place the handle in your ear and place the other end of it on the alternator, valve covers water pump and so forth. It will act like a stethoscope and should help with isolating it. (Of course if you happen to have a stethoscope use that...) I realize this sounds crazy but it works well.

You can check for exhaust leaks by running your hand near the meeting surface of the head and header (obviously don't touch them or get your hand too close) you should be able to feel any leaks.
Robert
1972 F100 Ranger XLT (445/C6/9” 3.50 Truetrac)

"An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it." -- Jeff Cooper
User avatar
robroy
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 3768
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 4:36 pm
Location: California, Salinas

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by robroy »

Hey Robert thanks for your excellent reply!
DuckRyder wrote:It is very hard to tell from the video.
Yeah I know what you mean. Thanks for checking it out though!
DuckRyder wrote:Take a long (and I mean long like pry-bar long) screwdriver, place the handle in your ear and place it on the alternator, valve covers water pump and so forth. It will act like a stethoscope and should help with isolating it. (Of course if you happen to have a stethoscope use that...) I realize this sounds crazy but it works well.
Okay, this is what I'll try next! I'll try a piece of long iron pipe, since I have that handy already.
DuckRyder wrote:You can check for exhaust leaks by running your hand near the meeting surface of the head and header (obviously don't touch them or get your hand too close) you should be able to feel any leaks.
Okay great! I thought about that but wasn't sure if exhaust leaks could be felt that easily or not. I'll give this a whirl.

Robert, thanks again for your great advice!
Robroy
User avatar
70_F100
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2999
Joined: Mon Oct 22, 2007 11:23 am
Location: North Carolina, Kernersville

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by 70_F100 »

Too rapid for an exhaust leak.

It sounds like something hitting thin sheet metal.

Check the inspection cover on your bellhousing.
Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools talk because they have to say something.--Plato
Why is it that there's seldom time to fix it right the first time, but there's always time to fix it right the second time???

That's not an oil leak :nono: That's SWEAT from all that HORSEPOWER!! :thup:
User avatar
robroy
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 3768
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 4:36 pm
Location: California, Salinas

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by robroy »

Hey 70_F100, thanks very much for your excellent advice!
70_F100 wrote:Too rapid for an exhaust leak.
Now that you point it out, I can imagine this being true. I was imagining that the rapid clicking could reflect the exhaust ports opening, but perhaps that's unlikely.
70_F100 wrote:It sounds like something hitting thin sheet metal.
I see what you mean!
70_F100 wrote:Check the inspection cover on your bellhousing.
That I will do! You know, I think your suggestion may be highly insightful. Now that you've mentioned it, I remember that I never achieved a fully satisfactory fit on the clutch inspection cover area. It just didn't fit very well, and I had to bend the starter location plate somewhat to suit. I didn't see any clearance problems at the time, but I'll pull this area apart and do a thorough inspection to be sure.

Robert, getting back to your earlier advice, I used a long piece of steel pipe to listen to various parts of the engine. Here's what I covered so far:
  1. Headers at the exhaust ports on both sides: OK
  2. Valve covers: OK
  3. Fuel pump: OK
  4. Oil filter adapter area: OK
  5. Alternator: OK
  6. Heads nearby the spark plugs: OK
I may fire it up again tomorrow and use this method to listen to the clutch inspection cover area!

Regarding the exhaust leaks, I followed your advice and felt around. It was actually hard to find an area of the exhaust that wasn't leaking! Those temporary, flexible, stainless stretches of tubing I used leak all over. I also felt leaks around the collectors, since they're not tightened down (to preserve the uninstalled profile of the ball-and-socket joint).

Yet while I was under there, it just didn't seem like any of the leaks were the kind that could produce a sound like that. I think 70_F100 may be on to something by saying that the sound is too rapid and suspecting a sheet metal clearance issue.

Robert and 70_F100, thanks for your super helpful advice!
Robroy
User avatar
DuckRyder
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 4893
Joined: Mon Jul 19, 2004 3:04 pm
Location: Scruffy City
Contact:

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by DuckRyder »

I tried to play the video on my desktop but it says a codec is missing, so I'm reduced to listening on the laptop.

I do agree it sounds like something on sheet metal, My first though was something perhaps hitting the alternator fan. Could also be the inspection cover. You can run it without the inspection cover for testing purposes.

It sort of sounds like two noises to me, in addition to the sheet metal noise it sounds like it has some valve train noise as well.

I wouldn't worry much about anything in the exhaust past the head to header joint at least not now.
Robert
1972 F100 Ranger XLT (445/C6/9” 3.50 Truetrac)

"An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it." -- Jeff Cooper
hazelnut
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 1928
Joined: Fri Oct 23, 2009 1:06 am
Location: Williamsburg,Virginia

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by hazelnut »

I havent seen the video but you might want to pull the coil wire(motor cant start) and the inspection cover and have someone bump your motor over while your under the truck and see if you see any fresh looking rubs anywhere inside the inspection area and have a look around with a flashlight.Sorry left out the most important part,block your wheels so the truck cant roll.
User avatar
robroy
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 3768
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 4:36 pm
Location: California, Salinas

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by robroy »

Good day Robert and Hazelnut, thanks for replying!
DuckRyder wrote:I tried to play the video on my desktop but it says a codec is missing, so I'm reduced to listening on the laptop.
Sorry about that. I know that the encoding I used wasn't widely supported, since it's so new. Next time I post a video I'll try to use an older, more established format.
DuckRyder wrote:I do agree it sounds like something on sheet metal, My first though was something perhaps hitting the alternator fan. Could also be the inspection cover. You can run it without the inspection cover for testing purposes.
This I will do!

The alternator fan looks OK and I couldn't hear anything unusual through my iron pipe (physically touching the alternator case and my ear).

This said, I did make a somewhat unpleasant discovery. When I put the pipe to my ear and touched the OIL PAN, the tapping sound came through loud and clear! Now I'm imagining the crankshaft hitting the windage tray in there or something.
DuckRyder wrote:It sort of sounds like two noises to me, in addition to the sheet metal noise it sounds like it has some valve train noise as well.
Okay! Welp I'll try to figure out them one at a time. Hopefully one of those sounds is just an artifact of my video camera's poor microphone, but we shall see!
DuckRyder wrote:I wouldn't worry much about anything in the exhaust past the head to header joint at least not now.
Yeah I see your point!
hazelnut wrote:I havent seen the video but you might want to pull the coil wire(motor cant start) and the inspection cover and have someone bump your motor over while your under the truck and see if you see any fresh looking rubs anywhere inside the inspection area and have a look around with a flashlight.Sorry left out the most important part,block your wheels so the truck cant roll.
Hey Hazelnut, that's a great idea. I may try that later today when I have a helper on duty!

Since I heard the sound pretty clearly from the oil pan area, it seems like I may need to rip that apart again.

But since that's a huge job, I'll take the clutch inspection cover off first and look around in there as well as I can.

If that sound truly is coming from the inside of the oil pan, what potential causes come to mind?

Thanks very much for the expert advice!
Robroy
User avatar
70_F100
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2999
Joined: Mon Oct 22, 2007 11:23 am
Location: North Carolina, Kernersville

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by 70_F100 »

robroy wrote:

Since I heard the sound pretty clearly from the oil pan area, it seems like I may need to rip that apart again.

But since that's a huge job, I'll take the clutch inspection cover off first and look around in there as well as I can.

If that sound truly is coming from the inside of the oil pan, what potential causes come to mind?

Thanks very much for the expert advice!
Robroy
Since the engine was run on a dyno prior to you getting it back, I wouldn't expect the noise to be coming from within the engine. If it is, I would call the rebuilder before pulling ANYTHING back apart. They should be responsible for anything and everything internal, since you have just fired it up for the first time. If you pull it apart without contacting them first, they may refuse to do anything for you if there is, in fact, a problem with the engine internals. :nono:

I'd first check the clutch area, as I said before. It's very possible that your pressure plate bolts are slightly too long, as I have a strong feeling that you may have replaced them with new ones. If you did, I hope you used the special bolts that are supposed to be used there. There's a good chance that they are hitting either the inspection cover or the engine spacer plate, and that sound could be transmitted to the oil pan due to their relative closeness. :hmm:

Since I know that pipe you've been using has to be somewhat cumbersome, you might try using a length of heater hose. You'll get the same results, and a lot more convenience. :thup:
Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools talk because they have to say something.--Plato
Why is it that there's seldom time to fix it right the first time, but there's always time to fix it right the second time???

That's not an oil leak :nono: That's SWEAT from all that HORSEPOWER!! :thup:
User avatar
robroy
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 3768
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 4:36 pm
Location: California, Salinas

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by robroy »

Hey 70_F100 thanks for replying!
70_F100 wrote:Since the engine was run on a dyno prior to you getting it back, I wouldn't expect the noise to be coming from within the engine. If it is, I would call the rebuilder before pulling ANYTHING back apart. They should be responsible for anything and everything internal, since you have just fired it up for the first time. If you pull it apart without contacting them first, they may refuse to do anything for you if there is, in fact, a problem with the engine internals. :nono:
I see your point!

In this case though, I actually did replace the oil pan, windage tray, and oil pump pickup tube. They shipped the engine with a rear sump, 4x4 pan on it, so I needed to swap those things out.
70_F100 wrote:I'd first check the clutch area, as I said before. It's very possible that your pressure plate bolts are slightly too long, as I have a strong feeling that you may have replaced them with new ones. If you did, I hope you used the special bolts that are supposed to be used there. There's a good chance that they are hitting either the inspection cover or the engine spacer plate, and that sound could be transmitted to the oil pan due to their relative closeness. :hmm:
Could be! My pressure plate bolts were these ARPs:

Image

About the sound being transmitted due to closeness, although this certainly could be true, I didn't hear much in the way of bad sounds from the inspection cover. It was a lot more prominent from the oil pan itself.
70_F100 wrote:Since I know that pipe you've been using has to be somewhat cumbersome, you might try using a length of heater hose. You'll get the same results, and a lot more convenience. :thup:
Oh okay! Yeah that will help a bunch. Thanks for the tip!

Thanks for the great advice 70_F100!!!
Robroy
User avatar
robroy
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 3768
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 4:36 pm
Location: California, Salinas

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by robroy »

I just called Steve at Proformance Unlimited, and he says that it's the windage tray hitting the crankshaft.

He said that this is a typical thing to happen, and that folks are supposed to rotate the engine all the way around by hand before buttoning the oil pan up. He mentioned that very often, the windage tray needs to be modified or bend somewhat to keep it from hitting the crank.

I noticed that the clearance between the crankshaft and the windage tray was pretty tight, but I didn't think to actually turn the engine over to see if it would hit anywhere. I trusted that the Milodon parts wouldn't be made incorrectly or have any manufacturing flaws. Ouch!

Steve agreed to listen to the video clip and get back to me, so maybe he'll have additional advice at that time.

Robroy
User avatar
robroy
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 3768
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 4:36 pm
Location: California, Salinas

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by robroy »

I've begun pulling off the inspection cover. Is it normal to have some clearance issues with the headers getting those off?

Thanks!
Robroy
User avatar
Ranchero50
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 5799
Joined: Wed Nov 08, 2006 7:02 pm
Location: Maryland, Hagerstown
Contact:

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by Ranchero50 »

Welcome to headers...

Sounds like the windage tray whacking just from the description (I can't see of hear the video...)
'70 F-350 CS Cummins 6BT 10klb truck 64k mile Bahama Blue

Contact me for CNC Dome Lamp Bezels and Ash Tray pulls.
User avatar
robroy
100% FORDified!
100% FORDified!
Posts: 3768
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 4:36 pm
Location: California, Salinas

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by robroy »

Hey Jamie thanks for your reply!
Ranchero50 wrote:Welcome to headers...
Thanks! I guess that's just the way these charming things are! So far I've unbolted the ball-and-sockets, disconnected the clutch linkage, and tilted the inspection cover around in every conceivable fashion. I'll figure it out yet!
Ranchero50 wrote:Sounds like the windage tray whacking just from the description (I can't see of hear the video...)
Yes I think that's the most probable thing at this point! Now that I know that I was supposed to check for crankshaft clearance after installing the tray, it makes sense. This may be painful but that's how inexperienced guys like me gain experience! Plus, if I need to remove the pan, I will have a custom drain plug installed this time (really)!

Thanks again Jamie!
Robroy
User avatar
DuckRyder
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 4893
Joined: Mon Jul 19, 2004 3:04 pm
Location: Scruffy City
Contact:

Re: What's this loud tapping sound from my new engine?

Post by DuckRyder »

Refresh our memory about which windage tray you used? I remember some discussion about an Milodon one and the Factory Cobra Jet style.

With the fact that it seems to be coming from the pan, I would not run it any more. It should be possible to manually turn the engine. (Pull the plugs, chock at least two wheels [on both the front and back of the wheel], and place the transmission in neutral).
Robert
1972 F100 Ranger XLT (445/C6/9” 3.50 Truetrac)

"An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it." -- Jeff Cooper
Locked